Usually I like discussions like these but in this case I agree with BadHorsie, it's getting kind of old. So long as we all keep in mind the following things, the world will be a better musical place.
1. Everyone is entitled to a different idea of what a "good" guitarist is.
2. Everyone is entitled to a different idea of what a "good" (replace "good" with any other loaded word of your choosing, ie., interesting, complicated, fun, enjoyable) style is.
3. "Music" has a different meaning for different people. It's not arranged just tones and rhythems.