View post (Analyze this!)

View thread

chris mood
High Bandwidth
Joined: 08/31/01
Posts: 1,319
chris mood
High Bandwidth
Joined: 08/31/01
Posts: 1,319
10/28/2003 6:28 am
Originally posted by Christoph


|-------0-----------0-----------0-----------0--------|
|-----1---1-------1---1-------1---1-------1---1------|
|---2-------2---2-------2---2-------2---2-------2----|
|-4-----------3-----------4-----------3--------------|
|----------------------------------------------------|
|----------------------------------------------------|

Aminor6/F# (i) Fmaj7 (6)

|-------1-----------0-----------1-----------0--------|
|-----1---1-------1---1-------1---1-------1---1------|
|---2-------2---2-------2---2-------2---2-------2----|
|-2-----------2-----------2-----------2--------------|
|----------------------------------------------------|
|----------------------------------------------------|


Fmaj7/E (6) Amin/E (i)*basically nothing more happening here than a chromatic bass line, the 6 chord in harmonic minor would normally resolve to the 5, does so in the bass (nice job Christoph!).



|----------------------------------------------------|
|-------2-----------0-----------2-----------0--------|
|-----0---0-------0---0-------0---0-------0---0------|
|---3-------3---3-------3---3-------3---3-------3----|
|-4-----------4-----------4-----------4--------------|
|----------------------------------------------------|


o.k., 2 ways of looking at this next pt..1)he switches to a A dominant tonality (C# in bass w/#5) or 2) he uses a b5 sub for the i chord (Eb9/Db with the root and 5th omitted). I kinda like the 1st expl. better, so I'll go w/that. The 2nd chord would just be A dominant #5 w/the doubled 3rd exchanged for the 9th.


|----------------------------------------------------|
|-------3-----------0-----------3-----------0--------|
|-----2---2-------2---2-------2---2-------2---2------|
|---3-------3---3-------3---3-------3---3-------3----|
|-2-----------2-----------2-----------2--------------|
|----------------------------------------------------|


A dominant is the 5/4 (d minor), Bminor 7b5 is just a sub for d minor (B D F A). Bminor7b5 is the ii chord of A harmonic / natural minor. Christoph changes the B tonality to a dominant9th chord, which would then be 5/5.



|----------------------------------------------------|
|-------------------1-----------------------1--------|
|-------2---------2---2---------2---------2---2------|
|-----3---3-----2-------2-----3---3-----2-------2----|
|---3-------3---------------3-------3----------------|
|-1-----------1-----------1-----------1--------------|


Instead of going directly to the 5 chord he resolves to the tri tone sub of B: F, which is also the 6 chord in harmonic minor, which either resolves by half step down to the 5 or subs for the 1. Nice Move!


|----------------------------------------------------|
|-------1-----------0-----------1-----------0--------|
|-----1---1-------1---1-------1---1-------1---1------|
|---2-------2---2-------2---2-------2---2-------2----|
|-2-----------2-----------2-----------2--------------|
|----------------------------------------------------|


Here he resolves it to the E (5 chord), tri tone motion in the bass ( alittle repetitive at this pt. would have rather heard chromatic half step resolution downward) adds sharp 5 in melody resolving to natural 5 for some nice tension and release.
[/code]



[edit]**fixed the table width problem**[/edit]

[Edited by Christoph on 10-28-2003 at 01:29 AM]