Originally posted by noticingthemistake

Chris. One post, what christoph wrote was clearly undiatonic, the next it's in A minor. Oh yeah by the way, since when is there a F#, and an F in A minor??

*A melodic minor contains F#, natural and harmonic F natural.
At 1st glance the 1st thing I noticed was the chromatic voice leading all over the place. After relooking at the chord progression and playing through it using Christophs tab expl. I can now see and hear a relationship to A minor.

About how I labeled the chords? They are the same notes and same chord just labeled different. Why even argue about that?? :confused:

----
-1--
-0-
-2-
-3-
--- I like to label this chord Eb#5b9/C !