View post (What's Up !?!)

View thread

chris mood
High Bandwidth
Joined: 08/31/01
Posts: 1,319
chris mood
High Bandwidth
Joined: 08/31/01
Posts: 1,319
10/27/2003 6:36 pm
Originally posted by noticingthemistake
What is beautiful about this movement is the psychological effect it has on the listener. Instead of the tension of the E7(b13) chord being resolved, it is continued on the Fmaj7/A chord.

*I agree

Leaving the listener with a sense of suspense and unresolved, which brings us to the C major chord next.

*this is where I disagree, if the next chord is C maj. then I would defintely label this chord as F.


Although the idea is there are two different phrases, the first in A minor which ends with E7(b13) to Fmaj7/A. Then a new one begins in C major. Point is the C major is not the final resolve, but Fmaj7/E. Re-voiced and renamed as Amaddb6, to make sense of a A harmonic minor cadence.

*your stretching things here.

Here’s a chord progression where it will work. Am - Dmaj - Am - G7 - Am - Dmaj - E7(b13) - Amaddb6.


*Dude, this chord progression sounds awfull, I hope you meant to write Dminor instead of major.