I'm not sure if this has been conversed about before...
What makes a "good" guitarist?
Is it ability/skill in the hands?
Is it knowlege of the fretboard?
Is it a the # of songs at his/her disposal?
Is it a good ear to play whats heard?

theres some more I'm sure...

One could know many songs,but lack advanced technique and an ear for music.
One could know few songs,but have able hands.
theres lots of combinations of qualitys.

I have able hands and a good ear,with small knowlege of the fretboard and a handful of songs people would recognize.

What qualitys make you up as a guitarist?
what qualitys make a "good"(by good,I mean recognized as good by non-guitar players)guitarist?

Break yourself down and find your strong points and weak.