Thanks for the explanation.
Follow up question.
- If I'm practicing the A minor scale and start on the 5th fret of the low E string (A note) and I'm calling out intervals. Should I call out 1 as the first note or 6 (relative to C major)?
- If I start with 1 and I get to the flat 3rd. Why is it considered the flat 3rd, when the note is C and not C flat?
Thanks in advance, Paul.
You're welcome.
If you're practicing the A minor scale, then A is 1 (C is 3 in this case). Whatever scale you are practicing the root note is always 1. It's important to think in terms of interval distance from the root note because that's what gives a scale its distinctive sound.
I think you might be conflating scale intervals & the musical alphabet, but they are two separate entities. They are both absolute & do not alter each other. The notes (A-G#) are where they are regardless of any scale. We simply use them as a static pattern to call out the notes when we land on them when applying any scale pattern.
The distance from the 1 (root note) of any minor scale to the minor 3rd of the scale is always 3 frets (or one and a half steps). Then wherever it happens to land on the musical alphabet, that's what note name it is. A to C is 3 frets, so an interval distance of a minor 3rd. It's just a matter of systemic coincidence that the A minor scale is the only one with no sharps or flats.
Let's say we're playing the G minor scale.
G (1) ws A (2) hs Bb (3) ws C (4) ws D (5) hs Eb (6) ws F (7) ws (G (1)
In this case we start on G and if we go up 3 frets to the minor 3rd we land on Bb. So in this case we find that the minor 3rd of the scale does happen to land on a flat note. But we don't make the B a flatted note because of the scale. The notes B and Bb are where they are regardless of any scale. And that's just where we land if apply the scale intervals.
I cover moveable scale patterns in these tutorials.
Major Scale Patterns https://www.guitartricks.com/tutorial/453/
Minor Scale Patterns https://www.guitartricks.com/tutorial/887/
Hope that helps!
Christopher Schlegel
Guitar Tricks Instructor
Christopher Schlegel Lesson Directory