Clicky

Em chord fingering


tavernphil
Full Access
Joined: 10/29/24
Posts: 3
tavernphil
Full Access
Joined: 10/29/24
Posts: 3
11/10/2024 7:12 pm

I’ve gone back to basics and started the course from the beginning. However in the early videos it’s shown to play the Eminor chord with middle and ring finger. I had always used 1st and middle and found it easier that way changing to Aminor or Cmajor. 
 Shall I get out of this old habit or is it not so important.  My idea had been to totally start from scratch. Already I’m getting lazy. 


# 1
ChristopherSchlegel
Full Access
Joined: 08/09/05
Posts: 8,834
ChristopherSchlegel
Full Access
Joined: 08/09/05
Posts: 8,834
11/11/2024 12:18 pm
#1 Originally Posted by: tavernphil

I’ve gone back to basics and started the course from the beginning. However in the early videos it’s shown to play the Eminor chord with middle and ring finger. I had always used 1st and middle and found it easier that way changing to Aminor or Cmajor. 
 Shall I get out of this old habit or is it not so important.  My idea had been to totally start from scratch. Already I’m getting lazy. 

In general, anyway you can get the notes to sound is fine.  So, either way is fine.


Backing up and looking at the bigger picture, the overall principle here is to use the most natural and efficient motion possible to play the music.  With that in mind, I encourage all students to put practice time into working on different fingerings.  We typically learn one way to play a chord, then stick with it as long as it works.  But you might come across a chord change in a new song that would benefit from using a different fingering on that chord.  So when you get to that problem, you work on the different fingering & add that to your skill set.


And the sooner you put time into any part of learning, the sooner it will become second nature to you.


In this particular case I think it's usually easier, more efficient motion to use your middle and index finger on the A & D strings.  Then moving from the E minor chord to the A minor chord, you keep those fingers together & simply shift them each over a string to the D & G strings.  Your index finger was completely free to hover in place until needed on the B string.  Using your index finger on the A string means you have to move all your fingers around more than absolutely necessary to get from E min to A min.


As long as your fingering works for you, and your can play the chords cleanly, in time, that's fine.  But I encourage you to work on that different fingering as well.  


Hope that helps!


edited

Christopher Schlegel
Guitar Tricks Instructor
Christopher Schlegel Lesson Directory

# 2
tavernphil
Full Access
Joined: 10/29/24
Posts: 3
tavernphil
Full Access
Joined: 10/29/24
Posts: 3
11/12/2024 11:56 am
#2 Originally Posted by: ChristopherSchlegel

In general, anyway you can get the notes to sound is fine.  So, either way is fine.


Backing up and looking at the bigger picture, the overall principle here is to use the most natural and efficient motion possible to play the music.  With that in mind, I encourage all students to put practice time into working on different fingerings.  We typically learn one way to play a chord, then stick with it as long as it works.  But you might come across a chord change in a new song that would benefit from using a different fingering on that chord.  So when you get to that problem, you work on the different fingering & add that to your skill set.


And the sooner you put time into any part of learning, the sooner it will become second nature to you.


In this particular case I think it's usually easier, more efficient motion to use your middle and index finger on the A & D strings.  Then moving from the E minor chord to the A minor chord, you keep those fingers together & simply shift them each over a string to the D & G strings.  Your index finger was completely free to hover in place until needed on the B string.  Using your index finger on the A string means you have to move all your fingers around more than absolutely necessary to get from E min to A min.


As long as your fingering works for you, and your can play the chords cleanly, in time, that's fine.  But I encourage you to work on that different fingering as well.  


Hope that helps!

Hi, thanks for the detailed reply. 
I think i found my old way easier because my middle finger would never have to leave the fret board when changing thru any of the 3 chords and i found having an anchor made it easier for me. 
 But after reading your reply i really should practice this new way as i understand what your saying. And it’s not always going to be these 3 chords im using. 
 Im really enjoying the course btw and wish i had more time to practice than i do. 


# 3
ChristopherSchlegel
Full Access
Joined: 08/09/05
Posts: 8,834
ChristopherSchlegel
Full Access
Joined: 08/09/05
Posts: 8,834
11/12/2024 12:06 pm

You're welcome.  Glad you're enjoying the course.  I understand about wanting more practice time.  It's a common problem.  Keeping working on it & best of success!


Christopher Schlegel
Guitar Tricks Instructor
Christopher Schlegel Lesson Directory

# 4

Please register with a free account to post on the forum.