As for a 1 to 4 progression I can name at least 2 dozen songs off the top of my head that utilize this function (Feeling Allright, Can't Always Get What You Want, etc..). I think the 4 chord definitely has its own unique aural character, In fact I think its one of the easiest and most distinguishable chords to hear within the diatonic system. Why you would want to invent some theory that disguises the relevance of the sub-dominate is beyond my comprehension.
*this sounds like a very interesting debate, unfortunately I have to run a music camp for the next 2 wks and will probably not be able to contribute....have fun guys.