#1
Originally Posted by:
Whune
D
A
F
G
to my ears it's an embellished Dm
(an added 4; as opposed to "sustained" (substituting the 3)
so would that be called a Dmadd4?
or
Dm/G?
or?
Context:
I came across on in a tut of "Lean on Me," using guitar to mimick the piano chords)
the guy doesn't name this chord;
but he says it's resolving the G6 before it;
but to my ears that's just an Em/G;
because there's no D in it
G
E
B
G
G
as I say that...
it might sense to me that it's sort of descending from Em, to Dm; over G (fifth of C)
so it's like it's pulling slowly down to the Tonic; but with all the tension of that Dominant pitch
i guess that's why it has so much longing in it?
anyways...
thoughts?
That's all just an extended harmony G (V) chord. You've got the right idea thinking of it as piano chords adapted to guitar. Guitarists typically look at & think of everything as a frozen, isolated vertical shape. So, you could think of it as Em/G to Dm/G. But the chords in that song are better thought of as triad voicings moving over the G bass note.
This matches the vocal harmony at the end of the line that sings an E down to a D. So if you harmonize that using the C major scale you happen to get an E minor chord to D minor chord with a G in the bass. But it's easier to think of it as all just a G chord with color tones.
|------------------------|
|--5-(6)-----3-(5)-------|
|--4-(M3)---2-(9)-------|
|--5-(1)-----3-(m7)-----|
|------------------------|
|--3-(1)-----3-(1)-------|
So, a G6 to a G9(no3rd).
The original piano part also moves down one more triad voicing to include what results in a G11.
|-------------------------------|
|--5-(6)-----3-(5)----1-(11)---|
|--4-(M3)---2-(9)----2-(9)----|
|--5-(1)-----3-(m7)--3-(m7)--|
|-------------------------------|
|--3-(1)-----3-(1)----3-(1)----|
G6 to G9(no3rd) to G11(no3rd).
If I was playing it with a band I'd just let the bass and, or piano play the low G & I would only play the upper descending triads. Kind of like just playing the right hand part of the piano. If I was playing it on solo guitar, then I'd try to add the low G on some of the chords.
Fun question! Hope that helps!
Christopher Schlegel
Guitar Tricks InstructorChristopher Schlegel Lesson Directory