I took a test on a website called themusiclab and it gives various sounds and you pick either one or two like which is the most out of tune song one or song two. I got correct on all of them, and it had a bunch of other questions and I got correct on all of them also, then It had "Which clip had beeps that were the MOST on the beat?" The beep sounded like a metronome beep, out of 14 of them I got 12 incorrect.

Something else I noticed, people always say tap your foot to the beat of a song when playing guitar, so I tried that earlier to songs over and over and over again, [I was using reaper to record audio of me playing with mp3 songs] and when I would listen back it was worse than usual meaning it was way way off.

I'm guessing this is not normal and is rare for someone to have this problem this bad?