Clicky

New beginner


344c
Registered User
Joined: 07/29/18
Posts: 2
344c
Registered User
Joined: 07/29/18
Posts: 2
08/31/2018 11:55 pm

Hi Everyone

I just turned 75 and been thinking about the type of music that I have enjoyed. Aside from Bolero, I really love Spanish and Flamenco Guitar. I searched for months and easily decided on Guitar Tricks and I find Lisa Mccormick to be an excellent instructor. I wasn't certain about the type of guitar to get. so, I listened to comparison videos of both Nylon string and Metal string guitars. To me, the metal string Acoustic guitars had the richest sounds. Now that I am doing the Spider exercises, I find that I am having problems with properly hitting the correct frets without touching adjacent strings. There doesn't seem to be enough room for my large hands and fingers. Maybe a Nylon string guitar would have been a better choice. Opinions welcome!


# 1
manXcat
Registered User
Joined: 02/17/18
Posts: 1,476
manXcat
Registered User
Joined: 02/17/18
Posts: 1,476
09/01/2018 1:14 am

Hello 344c

Possibly not. Many beginners have issues with developing the initial coordination and motor skills required of fretting. Using all of our fingers, especially the ring and little finger which are seldom used for such tactile tasks in our occupations and everyday life in general. Exacerbating that, we're asking it of our the alternated hand fingers of our individual handedness.

Most contemporary acoustic (steel stringed) guitars have fairly standard scale length, nut widths, string spacing, radius and neck profile. But with an increasing trend driven by end user demand, to offer choice in growing markets, an increasing nmber especially of those falling into the category where they might be chosen as a beginner guitar, are made to be friendlier to medium and smaller hands. You might want to investigate the specs of or measure your guitar.

IME guitars, their necks in the particular are like shoes. One size definitely doesn't fit all. e.g. Yamaha APX600 now has a string spacing of just 10mm. That's narrow, compromising open A fretting for all but the most skinny fingered. Correct technique in how one holds the neck and curls the hand around for the fingertips to fall precisely with first joint perpendicular in the cramped space is imperative for a sounding of all three notes of the fretted D,G,B strings without inadvertant muting regardless of alternative multiple fingerings used, with the exception of the single ring finger fretted A which can compromise the 1st E string. On a similar style of guitar with wider string spacing, e.g. Cort AF515CE, space available and finger placement is more forgiving. Legendary American brands usually have wider nuts, string spacing and necks catering to larger hands IME.

As for nylon vs steel strings. No question. Nylon is gentler on the fingertips to fret. It won't solve a string spacing or developing co-ordination issue though. Awareness, technique and repetition until rote will. If I might make the suggestion.Spider fingers exercises will really help a lot in developing individual finger coordination, strength, flexibility and stretch or span.


# 2
LisaMcC
Guitar Tricks Instructor
Joined: 11/02/06
Posts: 4,068
LisaMcC
Guitar Tricks Instructor
Joined: 11/02/06
Posts: 4,068
09/02/2018 2:05 pm

Welcome to the guitar! The problems you are describing are very common frustrations among beginners, so don’t worry - you're definitely not alone!

As far as nylon vs. steel, I’d stick with the sound you love the most at this time. Getting your fingers in just the right spot in the Spider Legs exercise is a journey - something you will continue to hone over time. Even if you are not landing it spot on at this point, the exercise is still really good for developing hand strength, coordination, and orientation.

consider the tone and placement issues to be a work in progress.

the way you describe it, it sounds like you’d want to work on getting as much of a top-down tippy-tippy-tip of your fingertips point of contact as possible. Hitting adjacent strings is often caused by the finger coming in at a bit of a angle, which can often be tweaked and improved with attention and intention and practice.

Have fun! - Lisa


Lisa McCormick, GT Instructor
Acoustic, Folk, Pop, Blues

Full Catalog of Lisa's Guitar Tricks Tutorials
Find Lisa on Facebook!
# 3

Please register with a free account to post on the forum.