View post (skill level on songs are not marked properly!)

View thread

compart1
Registered User
Joined: 06/27/09
Posts: 1,410
compart1
Registered User
Joined: 06/27/09
Posts: 1,410
02/17/2015 3:27 pm
Originally Posted by: john of MTRhythm and strum patterns, chords (open, barre, caged, voicings...), riffs, timing, lead playing, picking (finger picking, alternate picking...), embellishments, tone control, and so much more go into a song. Each can have their own degree of difficulty and that difficulty can be/is different for each player.

I imagine the difficulty rating on the songs are the instructor's or group of instructors opinion of the complexity of the song. But one factor that the ratings can't address is your and my capability when we choose to sit down and learn a song. What is easy for you may be hard for me. I might be able to handle the strumming and rhythm of all the chords but be crap on the riffs. You might handle riffs but can't do a barre chord. Lots of variables...and a single icon of some number of guitars is not gonna address them all for all players.

Moreover, I think there's some weakness in the concept of searching for songs on the basis of someone's/anyone's opinion of the difficulty of each of the songs listed. If I looked for songs that match what I think my level of chops is there's a whole bunch of songs I'd miss and wouldn't be playing now. Instead, I always start a new song because I like the song. But all that is an opinion too. :D


John hit the nail on the head even with the nail moving..