John - you make some good points. I have researched guitars and stuff online and there are deals to be had. My personal experience makes me reluctant.

I've heard great things about sweetwater where they will help you over the phone and take back instruments if there are problems. I would probably deal with then. When you are looking for something specific, it makes it easier.

I've always lived where there were a number of music stores around - large and otherwise, so I'm spoiled in that regard.