The movie actually made me lke metallica again (after load), and helped me to undestrand St. Anger, sure... it would be intresting to have some kind of directors cut (couse it's being very discussed that James and Lars could have A LOT to do in the editting room, being such control freaks they both are).

I think it's honest in some points... i really like the catarthic chat with Dave Mustaine, and some of the fights... but I'm aware that maybe it's just what Metallica wanted us to see bout Metallica's problems.

Bottom line I like it enought to buy it and watch it a couple of times.