Sounds like a modeler to me. Not sure how to describe what's missing from it though :o. Were you using a chorus on the lead? That might be what's throwing it off. That and maybe a different cabinet and/or mic model would sweeten it up a bit. Not sure if you do this or not, but I always have two sets of patches... one for recording, and one for going through an amp, because they're going to sound so different. One won't work with the other usually.