Clicky

View post (chord structures)

View thread

JoeNovice
Registered User
Joined: 03/24/02
Posts: 31
JoeNovice
Registered User
Joined: 03/24/02
Posts: 31
12/20/2005 2:55 am
This is like talking to a horse with blinders on. Open up your mind and stop being so ANAL! :mad:

Equator....
Ok. I can answer that real quick, with the same link you are talking about:


Do you not read what I write. Never did I say anything about Neopolitian Ice Cream followed by a question. You didn't even respond to the questions I posed you directly. Here are the questions I asked you.
What's the difference between E Nepolitian Minor and E phrygian? Do you use one in a special situation? Are they EXACTLY the same?

What books do you have with this subject?


And in case you didn't read it the first time;
Most of the other links you provide state exactly what you say and you are probably right but it doesn't change the fact that it's the same thing as E phrygian


And showing the difference in interval structure between starting points in a scale PROVES NOTHING in a functional sense.

This is a question.... feel free to respond to this.... please dont answer something I have not asked.

If you improvise using the A minor scale [2122122] over C , F, and G, does this sound like A minor or C major to you?