All Time Fantasy Band

Originally Posted by: Jolly McJollysonIf he knew better, Jimmy Page wouldn't be IN the band.

Why?.....Isn't Jimmy Page one of the Greatest ever? :(.

For me he is ONE of the best Rhythm Guitarist ..not to mention, the most influential. I dont just base it on technical skill but also on overall impact and influence. That earned him a ticket there. :p

Originally Posted by: FretfireWhy?.....Isn't Jimmy Page one of the Greatest ever? :(.

I'm not exactly sure, but he could well be refferencing either Jimmy's notoriously sloppy playing or tendency to engage in plagiarism.

Originally Posted by: Jolly McJollysonyup, sure can

Well, you are one talented man then.

Originally Posted by: RaskolnikovI'm not exactly sure, but he could well be refferencing either Jimmy's notoriously sloppy playing or tendency to engage in plagiarism.

Ahh...okey...I thought Jolly was questioning Jimmy's greatness.

I agree with that sloppy playing thing....I've seen him play "Stairway solo" on VH1 live, and his pick really miss some strings sometime and he played it not that clear as on their album.....but what about the Plagiarism, can you please give some song he plagiarise?

I was really surprised, I never thought he would do that....Thanks :)

Originally Posted by: FretfireAhh...okey...I thought Jolly was questioning Jimmy's greatness.

I agree with that sloppy playing thing....I've seen him play "Stairway solo" on VH1 live, and his pick really miss some strings sometime and he played it not that clear as on their album.....but what about the Plagiarism, can you please give some song he plagiarise?

I was really surprised, I never thought he would do that....Thanks :)

Stairway to Heaven, for one. Stolen from the Spirit song "Taurus"

"Dazed and Confused" was written by Jake Holmes, but he is given no credit by Zeppelin.

"In My Time of Dying" Words stoplen from Blind Willie Johnson and phrasing taken from Josh White.

"The Lemon Song" is actually Howlin' Wolf's "Killing Floor"

"Whole Lotta Love" lyrics are from the Willie Dixon blues "You Need Love."

Jimmy Page is the riff master, but that's all he's got.

Originally Posted by: Fretfire
Jimi Page.

this is what you should know better JIMMY PAGE/JIMI HENDRIX
p.s you guys drink tons of wild turkey and sleep a few days every week while on the road and see if your playing gets a little sloppy.

Originally Posted by: z0s0_jpthis is what you should know better JIMMY PAGE/JIMI HENDRIX
p.s you guys drink tons of wild turkey and sleep a few days every week while on the road and see if your playing gets a little sloppy.

Or I could be a professional and try to put on the best performance possible for my audience every night.

Originally Posted by: Jolly McJollysonOr I could be a professional and try to put on the best performance possible for my audience every night.

so your shows are better than zeppelin???

Originally Posted by: Jolly McJollysonJimmy Page is the riff master, but that's all he's got.

hhhmmmmmmmmm....."giant fighting robot" vs. "achilles last stand"

Originally Posted by: z0s0_jphhhmmmmmmmmm....."giant fighting robot" vs. "achilles last stand"

Ouch...


I think that there is a bit of misunderstanding here... from what I understand, z0s0_jp is contesting the spelling of Jimmy Page, not his musicianship/songwriting abilities. That's what he meant by "you should know better" (at least, I think so)-- that "Jimi" means "Hendrix" and "Jimmy" means "Page".

How can he not be a Zep fan with a username like "z0s0"?

i think "giant fighting robot" is a great song jolly, don't get me wrong. i know you are intelligent but your statements about page are making me suspect ;) and yes, it was the spelling of jimi/jimmy

Originally Posted by: FretfireAhh...okey...I thought Jolly was questioning Jimmy's greatness.

I agree with that sloppy playing thing....I've seen him play "Stairway solo" on VH1 live, and his pick really miss some strings sometime and he played it not that clear as on their album.....but what about the Plagiarism, can you please give some song he plagiarise?

I was really surprised, I never thought he would do that....Thanks :)

You Shook Me is a blues song written by Willie Dixon and J.B. Lenoir. Earl Hooker first recorded it as an instrumental which was then overdubbed with vocals by Muddy Waters in 1962. It was later recorded by various rock musicians, including Jeff Beck on his album Truth and most famously by the rock group Led Zeppelin on their debut album. On the Zeppelin recording John Paul Jones double tracked the organ and the electric piano.

Since the Zeppelin version was released in 1969, one year after Beck's, he accused them of stealing his idea. The Zeppelin version is one of the few songs to showcase the talents of all four members, and the band played it frequently at their early live shows. It was the first of their songs to feature the call-and-response blues style of music.

Led Zeppelin did not originally credit Dixon for the song. He sued, won a substantial amount of money, and his name was placed in the credits.

Retrieved from "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/You_Shook_Me"

Originally Posted by: z0s0_jphhhmmmmmmmmm....."giant fighting robot" vs. "achilles last stand"

Haha, well, certainly the riffs in Achilles Last Stand are better than those in Giant Fighting Robot. As I said, riff master. Lyrically, I think Giant Fighting Robot is better. That's my story and I'm stickin' to it.

Funk Metal, and they're all still alive too.

Lead: Buckethead
Rythm: Tom Morrello
Bass: Flea
Vocals: Phil Anselmo
Drums: Brian "Brain" Mantia

Originally Posted by: Jolly McJollysonHaha, well, certainly the riffs in Achilles Last Stand are better than those in Giant Fighting Robot. As I said, riff master. Lyrically, I think Giant Fighting Robot is better. That's my story and I'm stickin' to it.

right on!!!

Alright Guys, Give me your best all time Punk Band.

Originally Posted by: Rsam16Alright Guys, Give me your best all time Punk Band.

I don't know about all that but,

Ozzy on vocals cuz thats a unique voice. Runner up Sebatian Bach

Niel Pert on Drums, I woulda went with Phil Collins but he wouldn't fit in anymore.

Steve Vai on one guitar, First choice would be Randy Roads but R.I.P.

I take Tony Iommi on the second.

I'm gonna agree with some and go with flea for Bass.

Originally Posted by: Rsam16Alright Guys, Give me your best all time Punk Band.

Guitar: Greg Ginn
Bass: Kira
Drums: Robo
Vocals: The whole damn audience singing "Loui Loui" for more than an hour

Originally Posted by: RaskolnikovGuitar: Greg Ginn
Bass: Kira
Drums: Robo
Vocals: The whole damn audience singing "Loui Loui" for more than an hour

Hey that ain't no punk all time band, it's Black Flag :confused:

Originally Posted by: Rsam16Hey that ain't no punk all time band, it's Black Flag :confused:

here's a Punk Band:
Vocals: The guy from Sum 41
Bass: Mark Hoppus
Guitar: The guy From Silverchair
Guitar2: The guy from Bush
Drums: Dave Groel

Imagine the Vocal harmonies.