I think you're asking a biased community about this one... it would be like taking a group of 17 year old cheerleading girls and ask them who was a better vocalist.... Freddy Mercury or Kelly Clarkson.......... well... we know which one they'll pick... and you know which one we'll pick. I actually listen to some Jimmy Eat World though... it's not too bad. It's different than most punk music out there. Ac/Dc is still a better band all around... music, vocals, stage presence, influencial stylings....... the whole package.