Just curious which version of this tune is better:

Version #1 Vocals by K. Taylor "Schmange"
http://s93744050.onlinehome.us/mp3/GoingHome.192.mp3


Version #2 Vocals by Duncan Wheeler - "Imaginary Band"
http://s93744050.onlinehome.us/mp3/GoinHomeNewDuncun.mp3

Many thanks for any opinions