In that case I think the one pickup I've mentioned you might like the most would be the Duncan Pearly Gates. If you like DiMarzios more than Duncans the DiMarzio PAF Pro you already mentioned is the closest match between the two companies. I'm normally more of a DiMarzio fan but as far as this individual pickup type goes I think Duncan has a slight edge. Just to repeat a little history lesson John Lowery from Manson used to use the PAF Pro (he also plays bluegrass and country professionally) and then switched over to the Duncan PG (except for the Duncan hot rails he uses on teles).

I'm assuming you want something with some vintage influence, if I'm wrong about that let me know.