When he was playing solo he sounded pretty good, but when he was playing with an accompiniast he sounded very rigid and unrelaxed. I would have to hear more of his stuff to make a sound judgement, but I can tell he comes nowhere near Paco. Pacos' rasguedo and tremelo's are amazing...he has the tightest tremelo I've ever heard, and he crescendos/descrendos with ease. Lets' not even mention Picado or Alzupau!
Tomatito is pretty good, but again no Paco.
I like Juan Martin a lot. Incredible legato and feel, he can play the simpliest thing and really make you feel it.
BTW...just saw Paco 2 weeks ago in concert...can you say AMAZING!!AMAZING!!