...some non theoritic players r better than those who r educated.
I couldn't agree more. There's some players with extensive theory knowledge that still suck compared to other musicians. The reason for this, I assume, is because guitar (as with any instrument) is a hands-on approach. You don't learn sweeping arpeggios in a theory book. You learn them by actually picking up the guitar and practicing.
There's a bunch of issues you guys addressed. Some interesting thoughts. I notice there tends to be lots of disagreement among these points.