Originally Posted by: revdave10

I'm not a noob, but I've only recently begun playing again after many, many years.[/quote][p]How much technique you had in the past is often a big factor in how quickly you can regain that skill level.

Originally Posted by: revdave10My question is: do I look at the shorter scale length and sacrifice tone, thinking it will be easier to play, or do I go for tone and hope I'll "work into" the longer scale length as I progress?[/quote]

Yes. If it's the difference between playing or not playing, then yes, you do whatever you can to play. Even if that means the tone is not ideal. Look at the alternatives you've set:

1. Play guitar with a less than ideal tone.

2. Do not play guitar.

That's a pretty easy decision if you really want to play guitar. :)

It's possible you can regain enough strength & dexterity to play a larger scale guitar, but it sounds like it could be a deal breaker for you if it doesn't.

Originally Posted by: revdave10What I need is perspective from someone who's taught guitar, understands physical considerations, and has experience seeing players progress physically. Is it feasible that my aging fingers will stretch out again with playing, or do I just need to accept some physical limitations?[/quote]

Both. As you practice you will certainly regain some strength & dexterity. But we all have certain limitations. You'll never know how much until you try!

[quote=revdave10] Or... is the half-inch scale length difference even enough to worry about?

That's a great question that I can't answer without seeing you play both guitars. I encourage you to try as many guitars as possible. There's no substitute for first hand experience.

[quote=revdave10]I'm really wondering how much of this is likely just "beginners clumsiness," and is likely to get better as I gain strength and get the muscle memory working?

There's only one way to find out. :)

[quote=revdave10]I can buy one guitar. I can't buy one and then "upgrade" later.

I'm not sure why you couldn't buy one, then trade it in or sell it to get another.

Hope that helps!