Yes, that example of Paganini is musical. And I genuinely loved it in the first link you posted.

But, I think you may have overlooked the relevance of "straw argument" in my previous reply. But never mind mate. We're here to share, express and hear different points of view, and I respect yours regardless.

I agree wth you that shredding when relevant and musical, and with those as its objectives, can be entertaining and pleasing to the ear as well holding the attention of critical discernment from the conscious mind. I noted Christopher's references to the salience of timbre, and it's given me food for thought and reconsideration of perspective.

I'll go and listen to your Crossroads link now.

[br]Cheers big ears!