I AM THE PIANO GUY. I have been doing piano for 10 years. I argued that the KEY SIGNATURES are the SAME but the minor SCALES- Harmonic AND Melodic have ACCIDENTALS in them which deviate from the key signature. So by simply moving them up the notes ARE the same but you are NOT playing a harmonic minor or melodic minor scale. I thought you "experienced" guitar players would know that or didnt u do theory exams!

PS I do play the guitar too so you are again mistaken!



[Edited by irg_lies on 11-18-2002 at 07:02 AM]