I use Jazz III's primarily (1.14mm). Lots of metal players use them.
The green dunlop tortex picks (.88mm) are my second go to picks. I think these are pretty much the "standard" of this size pick that people use.
Then the yellow ones (.73). If I remember, Buckethead uses these. I use lighter strings for strumming stuff.
There are always general rules of thumb, but at the end of the day, whatever feels best to you is the right pick.