You might post a recording of the song as-is, maybe me or someone else can point you in the right direction as to what you should play (in general, I mean.) Failing that, post what chords you are using and anything else that might be relevant (actually, I'd do that anyway), the style, and what mood you're going for with the lead.
I would also suggest getting a guitar teacher. Reading material online and being involved in guitar-oriented forums is also great, but it can't tell you if your technique is slowly tearing apart your shoulder or if you're on the highway to carpal tunnel. I avoided getting one for years, but I have been taking lessons for the last two and a half months and it's the best thing I have ever done.
---Bryan