I agree, I'm not saying it's totally bad. The thing is, it's all subjective. You can't word it like a sporting event, because they're is no clear winner. I think it's great to tell why you like one guitarist over another, but to just say, Dimebag wins, Hammett sucks. There's no discussion there.
But if I was asked who was better, and why? I would have a totally different answer.
And it wouldn't be so bad if they just didn't put all of them stupid threads up, like I mentioned previously.
Sometimes I hit notes only dogs can hear.