If it was me, I would go with the Ibanez but thats because I'm into heavy fast stuff. It all comes down to the type of music you like and the playing style you are trying to achieve. Personally I don't like Gibons (or Epiphones) or Fenders because I am so used to playing wafer thin necks with ultra low action. I also prefer the tone from humbuckers becuase they suit heavy styles. Nothing against Fenders or Epiphones, some nice models out there - just not my cup o' tea.