For example, in an EAB shuffle, to barre the A, go up to the 5th fret, and bar with the index finger across the 5th fret, and make an "E" formation with the other 3 fingers. To play the shuffle, you're going to move your pinky around, (ala SRV, "The House Is A Rockin"), but you don't have to bar all the strings to make this sound right. Just the bottom 3.
And so on. Get it? Ease up on the index and just barre what you need to. PLC