Originally Posted by: CSchlegelBTW - I wouldn't say using tab is "cheating" per se. The 2 biggest problems with tab are: typically it doesn't contain rhythmic info & it's not standardized music notation (it doesn't translate automatically to any other instrument).

But tab is a great way for beginners to learn. I have seen too many "proper" musicians look down on tab as bad. And too many DIY musicians look down on music notation as "unnecessary". They both have their uses. Ultimately, a guitarist should be able to use both.

Great Point. Tab is a tool. A newer tool but one none the less. Music notation is an older tool but still one used to this day. Like any art you must learn the tools that will open your creativity.

I think it comes down to maturity and wisdom in the musician.
A mature/wise musician will know that there are many ways of learning/doing things and look at all methods with an open eye and not be judgemental (take what you want leave/forget the rest).
An immature/unwise musician will be rigid and veiw their opinions as the "Only Way".
Such is life as they say and maturity and wisdom in our musicianship should also be a goal to acheive like scales and modes:)

2 cents