Originally Posted by: magicninjaA college music theory teacher would fail you if that was your answer on a test. Jolly is 100% right on this one. It has nothing to do with the note being the same as a G. It has to do with the TERMINOLOGY. Anywhere you read those chord construction were either a. dumbing it down for people who aren't this into theory or b. Dumb themselves or C. lazy. Saying there is no augmented 2nd isn't restrictive it's dead wrong.
I GUESS i am really gonna eat some crow on this. I was thinking of chords not intervals. It seems to me that it al boils down to that. What would we call this E G# D F## or E G D G ..... RTO :)