Here's some cars I'd consider:

Audi S4
284 hp, 4WD

Audi S2
230 hp, 4WD

BMW M5
315 hp, RWD

Nissan Sunny GTi-R
230 hp, 4WD

Toyota Celica GT
180 hp, FWD

Toyota Supra
240 hp, RWD

Mitsubishi 3000 GT
230 hp, 4WD