Too many overdubs - This I hate more than anything else. You have a band with ONE guitar player. But all of their songs have, like, FIFTEEN different guitar tracks. If you're a one-guitar band and you play a solo then there should be no rhythm guitar during the solo. It's simple math: one guitar=one guitar part. If you want two guitars then get two guitar players. Anything else is cheating. It's dishonest, a misrepresentation of what your band really sounds like.

cometzero